MRI tube image

Have you had trouble getting an MRI lately? You’re not alone.

A shortage of radiologists nationwide has meant that magnetic resonance imaging studies can be delayed, or their interpretations can be delayed. Those trying to hire radiologists have found themselves offering bigger and bigger paychecks. And there’s no end in sight.

“[X] has been in the hospital countless times & it always seems like she’s waiting for a MRI. They claim they’re so backed up that they’ll come at wake her up at 2am to do one,” a Florida woman wrote of her partner in an online discussion.

“There is a palpable shortage of radiologists in practices and academic departments across the United States, with more than 1,400 physician positions posted right now on the ACR job board, ” James M. Milburn,  MD, chair of the neuroradiology committee for the American College of Radiology Commission on Economics, wrote over at the A.C.R. Bulletin “As the need for radiology exams and services has increased, the number of radiology and nuclear medicine physicians graduating from training programs has fallen behind.”

Shortages elsewhere too

To be sure, there are shortages of doctors in many fields. People are waiting longer and longer for appointments, both for primary care and for specialists, and in some places wait times in hospital emergency departments have reached catastrophic levels.

The radiologist issue figured in a discussion on X Twitter recently, when a radiologist from Iowa tweeted that an employer offered a radiologist job with $1.1 million potential income. The employed hospital position offered $35,000 annual student loan reduction, and 13 weeks of paid time off.

“‘1.1 Million Income Potential’ I’ll say it again. There are no Radiologists left to hire,” Scott Truhlar tweeted.

An emergency medicine doc asked: “Is this why my StatRad reads at night which are contracted to be read in 45 minutes are taking 4-5 hours thereby making my job profoundly unsafe? I’m making very important decisions based on my review of CT scans and I’m going to get burned at some point. Can’t do EM this way.”

Truhlar replied: “Most likely. The nighthawk/telerad companies (our professions traditional “pop off valves”) are understaffed as well. They’re raising their prices to try to attract Rads, but there are no Rads to be hired at basically any price. Hopefully new AI can make us more efficient . . .?”

The response: “It’s bad, man. Making me reconsider my career as a nocturnist.”

And a reply: “Not good for you, us, or patients. There’s roughly two *advertised* Radiology jobs for every Radiology resident being graduated per year. And as you know, many jobs, often the better jobs, never get advertised.” (I reached out to Truhlar for comment, but he didn’t respond.)

Weeks-long delays

Newspapers are reporting similar trends. “The radiologist shortage is forcing patients in Michigan to face weeks-long delays for diagnostic imaging, according to a report published April 28,” Mary Stempniak wrote over at Radiology Business. “This has led to some individuals hitting online forums to express frustration about delayed test results, the Detroit News reported. Numerous hospitals are grappling with unfilled positions and exam backlogs, Michigan Hospital Association CEO Brian Peters told the news outlet.”

A person on Reddit complained: “It’s been over a week and still waiting to get my MRI and CT Scans read! Looks like they lost some staff in the merger, you would think they’d be required to let folks know they were going to have an issue reading them! Very disappointed!”

Another: “Our patients are still waiting like 20 days to get their results back. Myself included “

Another: “I’m in west Michigan, and my MRI results still aren’t available,  3 weeks and 2 days and nothing. All while I sit in extreme pain and very little help from my dr. What are we supposed to do? We’re at their mercy, but I promise them or their family and friends don’t have to endure this type of treatment. I feel for the people who have tumors growing while awaiting their results. It should never take nearly a month to get any test results.”

For a woman named Miranda Featherstone, writing in The Atlantic, the delay was terrifying. “A mammogram proved harder to come by than I’d imagined. When I finally secured an appointment, I brought my sister because I was so certain that something was very wrong. It turned out, crushingly, that my worry had not been prophylactic. The radiologist was nervous and somber; she told us that she was ‘very concerned’ by the mass in my breast and my lymph nodes, but that the hospital couldn’t offer me a biopsy for weeks. Basically, I had cancer, but no one could tell me anything more about it. Patting my arm as if I were a recalcitrant dog, she sent me to a nurse practitioner down the hall who tried to pick up the pieces of my life.”

Of course, this doesn’t apply to everyone. A Minneapolis man wrote: “I’ve had a couple of MRIs and no real problem getting in. With telemedicine, I assume they were read somewhere else. But the hospital near me has late evening MRIs available and I was able to get in without much wait if any.

“But my need wasn’t acute or anything. Let’s just say it was harder to schedule with my work schedule than the clinic schedule. And here in Minneapolis of course there are tons of options. So sometimes the answer may be not going where they refer you and making your own choice.” He said his most recent MRI was last year.

Offsite readings

A Midwestern anesthesiologist wrote in an online forum on the topic: “Shortage of radiologists is the specialty I least fear shortage. We have a bit of a shortage in our area mostly because a buyout led to an increase in early retirement. But this has been offset by using off-site frequently out-of-country outsourcing of mainly call coverage. Can’t do that with most other specialties.”

A hospital executive in the Western United States wrote: “The radiology group we contract with outsources after-hours reads. Same for the rural hospitals around us. … The issue is quality of the reads and responsiveness of those nighthawk providers.

“Delays in CT and MRI availability for us is due to not having enough techs not so much the rads.”

Milburn wrote: “The number of students matching into radiology residency positions through the National Resident Matching Program  was 1,084 in 2010, and in 2023 there were still only 1,006 matched into diagnostic radiology and 123 into interventional radiology, with 100% of positions filled. Census data  shows the growth of the U.S. population over age 65 increased 38.6% from 2010 to 2020, suggesting that we are not training enough radiologists to meet the needs of our aging population.”

As the X Twitter thread noted, wages are rising in radiology. “Between 2019 and 2023, [radiology] professionals saw their median total compensation climb 17.89% as practices upped their offers to best the competition,” Radiology Business wrote. “Meanwhile, executive management positions saw compensation increase 37.89% during the same time, ahead of managed care administrative staff (26.88%) and patient accounting professionals (21.42%).”

The publication also offered 17 strategies to combat the shortages, including hiring retired radiologists, hiring part-timers, using seasonal workers and international medical graduates, using teleradiology for nighttime and weekend hours, discouraging unneeded radiology exams and other tactics.

Gains from AI?

There have been some gains in radiology interpretation from artificial intelligence, but the gains so far seem to be experimental and not yet in widespread use. There seem to be more questions than answers.

“The AI model could lead to more efficient diagnoses, better treatment decisions and improved outcomes for patients,” one article promises.

Another says: “AI May Help With MRI Interpretation During Prostate Cancer Detection.”

A third: “A magnetic resonance imaging device built with off-the-shelf parts and paired with AI matched the performance of high-end MRI machines, according to a study published Thursday that could pave the way for greater access to the life-saving tools.”

The Associated Press asks: “Will AI replace radiologists, or just make them better than ever? Opinions differ on how much physicians should be embracing the technology.”

Surgeon shortages

The Midwestern anesthesiologist wrote that in his view, shortages in other specialties are more ominous.

“Vascular surgery, heart surgery, other surgery specialties that are not reimbursed like ortho,” he wrote. “The next generation of surgeons is not ready for prime time when they come out, and some fields just don’t pay enough relative to get enough good applicants.

“I know my field, anesthesia, it is harder to find new people, and for better or worse they do not want the hours that a lot of groups work.”

Jeanne Pinder  is the founder and CEO of ClearHealthCosts. She worked at The New York Times for almost 25 years as a reporter, editor and human resources executive, then volunteered for a buyout and founded...