young troubled woman using laptop at home
Photo by Andrea Piacquadio on Pexels.com

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has proposed a rule that would remove medical bills from most people’s credit reports, help to increase credit scores and loan approvals, and prevent debt collectors from using the credit reporting system to force people to pay.

“The C.F.P.B. is seeking to end the senseless practice of weaponizing the credit reporting system to coerce patients into paying medical bills that they do not owe,” said C.F.P.B. Director Rohit Chopra in a press release about the move. “Medical bills on credit reports too often are inaccurate and have little to no predictive value when it comes to repaying other loans.”

The proposal would stop credit reporting companies from sharing medical debts with lenders and prohibit lenders from making lending decisions based on medical information. 

Chopra is living with Stage 4 cancer and is familiar with the problems caused by medical debt.

Prohibition, exception

In 2003, through the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act, Congress said lenders could not get or use medical information, including information about debts. But federal agencies issued a regulatory exception to let creditors use medical debts in their credit decisions.

The C.F.P.B. is proposing to close the regulatory loophole and make sure that medical information does not unfairly damage credit scores. It would also help keep debt collectors from forcing payments for inaccurate or false medical bills.

Chopra wrote in a Reddit IAMA on Thursday, “in 2022, after the CFPB published research about the use of medical bills in credit reports and scores, the three credit reporting conglomerates (Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion) announced they would be taking a chunk of medical bills off of credit reports. We analyzed this carefully, and we still find that there’s a substantial amount left. In addition, while the credit reporting conglomerates did this voluntarily, the rule, if finalized, would prevent them from giving it to creditors.”

He added: “They took some actions voluntarily. For example, they took off certain medical bills below $500. The proposed rule would cover all medical bills and it would be mandatory.”

Comment period

The C.F.P.B. has proposed the rule, and the next step after the public comment period would be for it to issue a final rule after assessing public comments. The rule would take effect after it’s published. The proposal relates only to credit reporting. It doesn’t affect individual debt collection court proceedings.

The proposal was published in the Federal Register and immediately sparked strong opposition from hospitals, debt collectors and others, and drew strong support from patients.

Nearly 700  comments have been received. The comment period closes Aug. 12. 

A sampling of comments:

From Ashley Schubach: “I agree that medical bills, especially those from emergency visits, should not go to the credit bureau. I was a young, single girl in my teens and 20s when I started having kidney stones that would send me to the ER. Sometimes I had insurance, other times I did not. Every time I went in, I’d leave with huge bills. Working minimum wage jobs, that were barely paying my normal bills, I couldn’t afford any new bills (especially bills that were thousands of dollars). These negative marks STILL affect my credit score. They should have nothing to do with whether I can get a vehicle or home. I vote that medical bills be taken off people’s credit scores.

‘Can’t afford to live alone’

From Shawn Loos: “Husband had double lung transplant from NSIP which the cause is unknown. We have had so much debt from last ten years even with insurance. And have debt sitting on our credit reports. Which is so unfair. In our mid 50’s. Both worked our entire likes and pay a lot for medical insurance. Current living with our daughter because we can’t afford to live alone right now.”

From Darrick Weeks: “While I understand the intent to protect consumers from the adverse impacts of medical debt on their credit reports, I believe this proposed rule could have several unintended consequences that would be detrimental to both consumers and the healthcare system.
“Firstly, medical debt is a significant factor for healthcare providers when assessing the financial risk of providing services. The ability to report unpaid medical debt to credit bureaus serves as an important tool for providers to encourage timely payment and manage their financial health. Removing this tool could lead to increased financial strain on healthcare providers, particularly smaller practices and rural hospitals, which could ultimately reduce access to care for patients. … Secondly, not reporting medical debt could lead to increased costs for all patients. When healthcare providers cannot recover costs from unpaid bills, they often have to offset these losses by increasing prices for other patients. …

“Additionally, medical debt is often given less weight in credit scoring models compared to other types of debt, acknowledging the unique nature of healthcare expenses.

“Instead of the proposed rule, I urge the CFPB to consider enhancing existing protections and promoting financial literacy among consumers regarding medical debt. Efforts could be made to improve billing transparency, streamline the dispute resolution process, and provide better resources for consumers to manage and understand their medical bills.”

Paying for grandchildren

From Syble Jones: “Most medical debt should not be reported with other debt. It is usually unexpected and extreme. At 78 years old, I have had to help pay for life saving surgeries for my great grandchildren to save their lives and to keep the families in their homes. Without our help they would have been evicted. Don’t allow families to be homeless because of unavoidable medical problems. Elective surgeries, however, should not be exempt.”

From Lee Rintantiemi: “I went through and read all the comments from people who are against this rule. I expected to see ‘compliance officers’ but not ‘health care workers’. It makes sense healthcare workers would be here, commenting about issues they’ve never had such as not being able to get a car loan or having to pay enormous amounts of interest just to buy a vehicle. It’s ridiculous a healthcare worker from any background would come here and express concerns about medical bills being removed from patients credit reports. Creditors and hospitals can still sue patients or get their money other ways, without destroying hard working Americans credit reports. Medical bills should never be a barrier or stop a person from purchasing a home or a vehicle, which are basic necessities.

“I fully support the C.F.P.B. in removing medical bills from credit reports and returning financial freedom back to hardworking Americans, who have had their lives and credit destroyed over these unfair and probably at times even illegal medical debt reporting and collecting practices. Millions and millions of Americans have suffered for far too long at the hands of predatory medical debt collecting tactics.”

Bills for late wife

From Richard Durkin: “When my wife passed away from Inflammatory Breast Cancer (a fast-moving disease that usually appears as stage 4), the medical bills for treatment before her death were over $250,000. Fortunately, we had health insurance that cut the cost to about $23,000. Unfortunately, there were follow-on bills that had been passed to a collection agency demanding payment. To keep these debts from appearing on our financially linked accounts I had to dispute these claims, which took effort but was successful. No one should have to deal with medical claims being placed on credit reports – it is hard enough dealing with personal loss.”

From Teresa Henning: “Hello I have an excessive emergency bill when I didn’t have health insurance. It is still on my credit bureau report. My credit score dropped from 810 to 691 because of emergency room and emergency room doctor defaulted. I do have job employer doesn’t offer health insurance. Now I have low blood sugar I skipped lunch got busy at work. I passed out in front of my house. That should not effect my credit score for over 7 years. Yes I should not skip meals but I do know how to manage money. I was worried about my job we were understaffed I stayed worked extra.”

From Caroline Corum: I started out as a cancer advocate – advocating for more and better treatments for cancer. I still do that, but I switched focuses because I very quickly heard from many going through treatment who said all the cures in the world would not help them if they could not afford the care.

“I am talking about people who have (or had) insurance. People who were responsible and played by the rules. But then they had the bad fortune to get sick. Some had plans with huge out of pocket cost and premiums. Did you know that the ACA family plans where I live have an out-of-pocket maximum of about $20 thousand a year? Who can pay that? Especially year after year if they have a long-term illness. Often, when people get sick, they lose their jobs. COBRA coverage may be $24 thousand a year or more for a family. Again, who can afford that? I think that I have heard or personally observed every nightmare version of health insurance coverage loss – or simply refusal to provide coverage. Including some couples who divorce strictly for financial reasons – so that the sick spouse doesn’t take the whole family down – financially – with them.

“I still find it amazing that we are the only developed nation in the world that seems to feel like it is perfectly fine for people to go bankrupt because they get sick or injured. If they can manage to stay afloat, let’s not add insult to injury by making these folks look like they are deadbeats who don’t pay their bills. That’s just not right.”

Jeanne Pinder  is the founder and CEO of ClearHealthCosts. She worked at The New York Times for almost 25 years as a reporter, editor and human resources executive, then volunteered for a buyout and founded...